The Stewarts in Carnlia, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland, and
Easter Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland
7 Line of the Stewarts of Dalveich
The Stewarts in Carnlia and Easter Glentarken are two separate sibling lines that each descend from Alexander Stewart in Ardveich, son of John Dubh Mhor Stewart of Dalveich. Of all the 8 lines that descend from John Dubh Mhor Stewart, this is the only line where the descendant generations since John Dubh Mhor Stewart are known and confirmed in unbroken line. This family begins in Glen Beich at the west end of the north shore of Loch Earn in beautiful historic Highland Perthshire, Scotland.
Like the other descendant lines from John Dubh Mhor Stewart, many of the families from this line left Highland Perthshire in the early 1800s and emigrated elsewhere — primarily to Canada and some to Australia.
This family is presented in more detail than most other families on our website because it is the site host’s own family.
Loch Earn viewed from Easter Glentarken – by Ryk Brown, Aug. 2023
Ancestors of the Stewarts in Carnlia & Easter Glentarken
The Stewarts in Carnlia & Easter Glentarken descend from the Stewarts of Dalveich, who descend from the Stewarts of Ardvorlich who are the senior branch of the Stewarts of Balquhidder.
Sources
In our research, we cite many documentary sources. Some of the most common ones that you will find referenced and abbreviated in our notes include:
- Duncan Stewart (1739). A Short Historical and Genealogical Account of the Surname Stewart…. (It’s actual title is much longer), by Rev. Duncan Stewart, M.A., 1st of Strathgarry and Innerhadden, son of Donald Stewart, 5th of Invernahyle, published in 1739. Public domain.
- Stewarts of the South. A large collection of letters written circa 1818-1820 by an agent of Maj. Gen. David Stewart of Garth, comprising a near complete inventory of all Stewart families living in southern Perthshire, including all branches of the Stewarts of Balquhidder.
- MacGregor, Gordon, The Red Book of Scotland. 2020 (http://redbookofscotland.co.uk/, used with permission). Gordon MacGregor is one of Scotland’s premier professional family history researchers who has conducted commissioned research on behalf of the Lord Lyon Court. He has produced a nine volume encyclopedic collection of the genealogies of all of Scotland’s landed families with meticulous primary source references. Gordon has worked privately with our research team for over 20 years.
- [Parish Name] OPR. This refers to various Old Parish Registers.
- For a full list of sources, click here.
Carnlia (in Dalveich), Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland
Carnlia was a former clachan settlement on the west side of Glen Beich at the west end of the north shore of Loch Earn, just east of the village of Lochearnhead in Balquhidder parish in historic Highland Perthshire, Scotland (present-day Stirling Council Area). It’s name derives from the Gaelic, Carn Liath, which means, “the grey cairn.” The settlement that was Carnlia is now extinct and deserted. Until a few years ago, all that was left was a pile of rubble, but even the rubble has now been cleared away to accommodate the modern holiday home development. In it’s heyday, Carnlia would have contained several stone and thatch cottages constructed around a mill. It was part of the Dalveich property and is not always distinguished separately from Dalveich in historical records.
Much of the socio-historical description of Easter Glentarken (below) would also apply to Carnlia.
Stobie’s Map 1783
Easter Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland
Including Morell and Jerusalem
Easter Glentarken was a former clachan settlement (now a ruin) on the east side of Glen Tarken at the east end of the north shore of Loch Earn, just west of the village of St. Fillans in Comrie parish in historic Highland Perthshire, Scotland (present-day Stirling Council Area). The name, Glen Tarken, may derive from the Gaelic, gleann na tearcan, meaning “glen of the cows.” (Peter McNaughton, Highland Strathearn.)
In the mid-18th century, the east side of Glen Tarken was comprised of three distinct settlements: Easter Glentarken, Morell and Jerusalem. Historical records do not always distinguish between them and sometimes use the name Easter Glentarken to refer to all three clachans collectively.
Easter Glentarken contained a community of impoverished flax weavers, barely eking out a living in houses built of stones with thatched roofs. Most of the inhabitants, including our Stewarts, were fluently bilingual. Gaelic was their native language spoken in the home, but the government schools forced them to learn English which aided them in doing business with Lowlanders to the south.
The Statistical Account of 1791, says, “The common language of the people is Gaelic and all the natives understand it; but many, especially the old, do not understand English; but, in order to acquire it, they must go to service in the Low Country.”
The name, Morell, likely derives from the Gaelic, mor ail, which means “big rock”, possibly named after the giant Ice Age era rock that stands nearby which is “as big as a house”. (Peter McNaughton, Highland Strathearn)
The choice of the name Jerusalem for the third settlement is likely a reflection of the religious piety of the inhabitants.
Morell [now a ruins, was] a township abandoned during the Highland Clearances of the early 19th century. The outlines of numerous buildings remain, an eerily peaceful place to wander amongst the ghostly stones of once lively crofts and savour fine views across the loch to the mountains of Ben Vorlich and Stuc a’ Chroin.
Beyond a high wooden gate, the waymarked path, which can be quite wet and muddy underfoot, leads through bracken and across rough pasture to a cottage and, behind it, Jerusalem. While the cottage, now a bothy used by shepherds, remains wind and watertight, Jerusalem has fared less well over the years, the tiny home and adjoining barn just a ruin, albeit one full of character. Together they formed part of the farming community of Easter Glentarken which, incorporating Morell, included 18 buildings, four kilns, various enclosures and a school said to have accommodated up to 60 children.
— James Carron, The Courier, 17 Nov 2018.
Glen Tarken shrouded in mist, viewed from the south shore of Loch Earn. – Photo by Ryk Brown, Oct. 2005.
Ryk Brown standing on the rubble that was Morell in Easter Glentarken viewing Loch Earh. – Photo by Ewan Brown, July 2023
Jerusalem in Easter Glentarken Gallery
Click here for a gallery of photos from Jerusalem in Easter Glentarken.
View from Morell in Easter Glentarken. – by Siuna Mayes
7 Line – The Stewarts in Carnlia and Easter Glentarken
The seventh line of descendants of the Stewarts of Dalveich is a family of Stewarts who came from Ardveich in Glen Beich at the west end of the north shore of Loch Earn. They descend from Alexander Stewart in Carnlia, a younger son of John Dubh Mhor Stewart in Dalveich. This is the only line that descends from the Stewarts of Dalveich for whom we know for certain which son of John Dubh Mhor Stewart the family descends from.
Alexander Stewart in Carnlia, son of John Dubh Mhor Stewart in Dalveich, had two known sons:
-
- Donald Stewart in Carnlia, whose descendants remained in Carnlia for several generations, and
- Robert Stewart in Ardveich whose family moved to the east end of Loch Earn where they resided at Morell in Easter Glentarken.
Stewarts of the South
This family is described about 1815 in Stewarts of the South as follows:
Alexander Stewart, who is a tacksman in Dalveich, Balquhidder parish on Breadalbane’s estate. He has three sons — one adult and two under age.
Robert Stewart – a feuer in St Fillans, Comrie parish, on Drummond’s estate. He has three or four sons under age.
Each of these men presented in Stewarts of the South, along with their children, are easily identifiable in the Balquhidder and Comrie parish records. The relationship between Alexander and Robert is not indicated in Stewarts of the South, but research shows them to be second-cousins. Alexander Stewart, tacksman in Dalveich, descends from the earlier Donald Stewart in Carnlia. And Robert Stewart in St. Fillans (designated here as Robert Stewart in Morell and St. Fillans) descends from Donald’s brother, Robert Stewart in Ardveich.
The Walker Family History
We are fortunate with this family that the descendants of Donald Stewart in Carnlia preserved a family tree going all the way back to James Beag Stewart, 2nd of Ardvorlich, and showing every generation in-between. That family tree is known as the Walker Family History. The level of detail shown for each line ought to give us good confidence in the accuracy and reliability of this account. The Walker Family History shows the line of descent as:
- James Stewart, B. about 1589. His mother was a sister to John Drummond Ernoch, Forester in Glenartney. (See Legend of Montrose) Born under tragic circumstances. Killed Lord Kilpont in a quarrel never yet explained)
- John Stewart, known as “Iain dubh (mac) Shemais” (Black John son of James)
- Alexander Stewart, resided at Carnlia, No Record
- Donald Stewart, resided at Carnlia, married a daughter of Alexander MacGregor [in] Woodside Lochearnhead. Don’t know her name, of Clan Dughail Chiar
- Alexander Stewart, resided at Carnlia, married Janet Stewart, Lochearnside. Her mother’s name was MacLaren
- Alexander Stewart in Cuilt, B. at Carnlia about 1809. Alexander Stewart (2) married Margaret Dewar, B. Killin about 1820. She was daughter of Alexander Dewar & Janet MacKay. Said Alexander Dewar was born at Nether Bolespie, and was the son of Duncan Dewar and Margaret MacGregor. Janet MacKay, B. Killin, her mother’s name was Janet Macnab, who was the daughter of Donald Macnab, Glendochart; Janet Macnab had a brother Duncan.
- Alexander Stewart, author of this account.
Walker Family History - Transcription
Who Am I?
- Alexander Stewart, B. 7th January, 1860
Son of - Alexander Stewart, B. at Carnlia about 1809
Son of - Alexander Stewart, resided at Carnlia
Son of - Donald Stewart, resided at Carnlia
Son of - Alexander Stewart, resided at Carnlia
Son of - John Stewart, known as (Iain dubh Shenman) Black John son of James
Son of - James Stewart, B. about 1589. His mother was a sister to John Drummond Ernoch, Forester in Glenartney
Alexander Stewart (2) married Margaret Dewar, B. Killin about 1820. She was daughter of Alexander Dewar & Janet MacKay. Said Alexander Dewar was born at Nether Bolespie, and was the son of Duncan Dewar and Margaret MacGregor. Janet MacKay, B. Killin, her mother�s name was Janet Macnab, who was the daughter of Donald Macnab, Glendochart; Janet Macnab had a brother Duncan.
Alexander Stewart (3) married Janet Stewart Lochearnside. Her mother’s name was MacLaren.
Donald Stewart (4) married a daughter of Alexander MacGregor � Woodside Lochearnhead. Don�t know her name, of Clan Dughail Chiar
Alexander Stewart (5) No Record
John Stewart (6)
James Stewart (7) (See Legend of Montrose) Born under tragic circumstances. Killed Lord Kilpont in a quarrel never yet explained.
2, 3, 4, 5, 6, & 7 are all buried in Ardvorlich Burying Place, Old Chapel of Dundurn, St. Fillans.*
Walker Family History - notes
Notes:
(7) James Stewart – The references above make it clear that this is Major James Beag Stewart, 2nd Laird of Ardvorlich.
(6) John Stewart (b ca. 1630) – He is recorded in the family bible as “Iain Dubh Shenman”. There is no such Gaelic word as “Shenman”. This would be a transcription error for Iain Dubh Sheamuis, or “Black John (of) James”. He would be synonymous with John Dubh Mhor Stewart of Dalveich, progenitor of this clan. As the original author Alexander Stewart was an award winning Gaelic scholar then it must be presumed that the original bible record is correct and that the error is in Alexander’s daughter’s transcription.
(5) Alexander Stewart (b. ca 1670) – Although the family bible gives no information on this Alexander other than that he resided at Carnlia, it is still the only documentary evidence we have for a confirmed son of John Dubh Mhor Stewart! This record and the next three generations allow us to plot the first reliable chronology of the generations of descendants of John Dubh Mhor. This Alexander is shown above as being the father of Donald Stewart. Descendant Donald Walker suggests that the following record could be this family:
Alexander Steuart and Janet Steuart had the following child:
-
-
- Donald Steuart, bap. 4 Sep 1720 in Auchleskine, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland.
-
(4) Donald Stewart – As Auchleskine is not far from Glenbeich, the Auchleskine birth above is a reasonable suggestion. Donald is recorded above as residing at Carnlia and having married a daughter of Alexander MacGregor of Woodside of Lochearn of Clan Dughail Chiar. (Also known as Clan Dugal Ciar, or the “Clan of Douglas with the sable coloured hair”. This was the chief’s family.) There are only two marriages in the Balquhidder or Comrie OPR for a Donald Stewart marrying any MacGregor in the right date range. This one happens to be in Dalveich (which for our purposes can be considered to be the same place as Carnlia). The other is shown below in the Commentary. Donald Walker shows this Donald Stewart tentatively as having been born in Auchleskine. Auchleskine was also occupied by a family of MacGregors descended from Sir Gregor MacGregor of Clan Dughail Chiar — so that too would be consistent. This Donald Stewart married on 10 Apr 1756 to Isabel McGregor with the following family. The children shown here match onomastically with Isabel’s family, but not with Donald’s.
-
- Mary Stewart, b. 11 Jun 1758 in Dalveich, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland
- John Stewart, b. 23 Mar 1760 in Dalveich, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland
- Catharine Stewart, b. 28 Jul 1762 in Dalveich, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland
- Jannet Stewart, b. 24 Jul 1764 in Dalveich, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland
- Alexander Stewart, b. 20 Jun 1767 in Dalveich, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland. This Alexander matches chronologically with the following…
(3) Alexander Stewart – He is shown above as having married Janet Stewart of Lochearnside, whose mother was a MacLaran. Again here there is an ideal match in the OPR with the following family. This would be the family of Alexander Stewart who married on 08 Dec 1792 in Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland to Janet Stewart. Alexander and Janet Stewart lived in Carnlia, near Dalveich. The fact that this couple have the right names and are found in Carnlia makes it virtually certain that this is the correct family. They had the following children:
-
- John Stewart, born in Carnlia and bap. 1794 Feb 2 in Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland.
- Donald Stewart, born in Carnlia and bap. 1796 Mar 20 in Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland. As Daniel is substitute name for Donald then it may be that this Donald died young prior to the birth of his younger brother, Daniel.
- Robert Stewart, born in Carnlia and bap. 1800 Jan 12 in Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland.
- Isabel Stewart, born in Carnlia and bap. 1802 Mar 28 in Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland.
- Patric Stewart, born in Carnlia and bap. 1804 Jun 17 in Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland.
- Margaret Stewart, born in Carnlia and bap. 1806 May 14 in Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland.
- Alexander Stewart, born in Carnlia and bap. 1809 Feb 12 in Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland.
- Daniel (Donald) Stewart, born in Carnlia and bap. 1813 Jun 4 in Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland.
Alexander’s wife, Janet Stewart is said to be the daughter of a MacLaren mother and lived on Lochearnside. There are only three Janet Stewarts who were the right age in Comrie or Balquhidder parishes and whose mother was named MacLaren. They are:
-
- Janet Stewart, bap. 21 Mar 1763 in Comrie, Perth, Scotland, daughter of Robert Stewart and Mary MacLaren, exact place not yet known.
- Janet Stewart, bap. 1 Feb 1767 in Wester Ardveich, Comrie, Perth, Scotland, daughter of James Ross Stewart and Catharine MacLaren, of 5 Line above.
- Janet Stewart, bap. 8 Oct 1769 in Glentarken, Comrie, Perth, Scotland, daughter of John Stewart and Margaret MacLaren of 7 Line above.
Entries 2 and 3 can both be described as “Lochearnside”, however the third one makes the most sense onomastically.
(2) Alexander Stewart – He is recorded as being born at Carnlia about 1809 and is a perfect match with the family above. He is recorded as having married Margaret Dewar from Killin, she being born about 1820. This family can be found in 1861 and later census records, but Alexander has not been found in the 1841 or 1851 censuses. They were married on 1 Jul 1856 in Killin and had only one child, Alexander, following:
(1) Alexander Stewart – He is recorded above as being born 7 Jan 1860 with no place given. However, his obit says that he was born at Cuilt. His baptism record is easily identifiable in the Balquhidder OPR as bap 7 Feb 1860 in Balquhidder. Census records show this family residing in 1871 in Auchtomore and in 1881 in Craggan, Strathyre. This Alexander later moved to Falkirk where he was a police officer and an award-winning Gaelic scholar and poet.
* This reference indicates that every male head of this family from John Dubh Mhor to the early 19th century are buried in Dundurn. This is an extremely significant reference as it confirms for us that Dundurn was not just the burial grounds for the Laird’s family of Ardvorlich, but for the entire Ardvorlich Clan. However, none of these persons from 2-6 are listed in Mitchell’s Monumental Inscriptions for Dundurn cemetery. Therefore it must be presumed that they are all buried in unmarked graves.
Balquhidder OPR data allows us to identify the family of Alexander Stewart in Carnlia who married Janet Stewart of Lochearnside. That family is shown below.
The Walker Family History information matches with this family’s description in Stewarts of the South.
Alexander mac Iain Dubh Mhor Stewart in Dalveich
John Dubh Mhor Stewart, of Dalveich, b. Abt 1630, Ardvorlich, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. Abt 1732, Dalveich, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland (Age ~ 102 years)
-
- Alexander mac Iain Dubh Mhor Stewart, in Dalveich, b. Abt 1680, Dalveich, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN, Carnlia, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland
John Dubh Mhor Stewart had eight sons who all grew to adulthood and had descendants. Alexander is the only son of John Dubh Mhor for whom we have any confirmed documentary evidence of his identity and for whom we have an unbroken descendant genealogy. Alexander is recorded in the Walker Family History as being a son of “Iain Dubh Shenman”, son of James Stewart of Ardvorlich. There is no such Gaelic word as “Shenman”. This would be a transcription error for “Iain Dubh (mac) Sheamuis,” or “Black John (son of) James”, known to us as John Dubh Mhor Stewart of Dalveich, progenitor of this clan. The following letter appears to be from this Alexander to his brother, Charles: “1713 – Letter by Alex Stewart to brother Charles Stewart of Dalveich. Herewith by (James Murray of) Strowan’s servant, your wallet and wife’s provisions.” (Garth Papers) Alexander’s descendants are shown as 7 Line – The Stewarts in Carnlia and Easter Glentarken.
Alexander Stewart had the following children:
- Alexander mac Iain Dubh Mhor Stewart, in Dalveich, b. Abt 1680, Dalveich, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN, Carnlia, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland
John Dubh Mhor Stewart had eight sons who all grew to adulthood and had descendants. Alexander is the only son of John Dubh Mhor for whom we have any confirmed documentary evidence of his identity and for whom we have an unbroken descendant genealogy. Alexander is recorded in the Walker Family History as being a son of “Iain Dubh Shenman”, son of James Stewart of Ardvorlich. There is no such Gaelic word as “Shenman”. This would be a transcription error for “Iain Dubh (mac) Sheamuis,” or “Black John (son of) James”, known to us as John Dubh Mhor Stewart of Dalveich, progenitor of this clan. The following letter appears to be from this Alexander to his brother, Charles: “1713 – Letter by Alex Stewart to brother Charles Stewart of Dalveich. Herewith by (James Murray of) Strowan’s servant, your wallet and wife’s provisions.” (Garth Papers) Alexander’s descendants are shown as 7 Line – The Stewarts in Carnlia and Easter Glentarken.
1. Robert Stewart, in Ardveich, b. Nov 1697, Dalveich, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland, d. 16 Apr 1746, Culloden, Inverness, Scotland
Robert Stewart, in Ardveich, b. Nov 1697, Dalveich, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. 16 Apr 1746, Culloden, Inverness, Scotland (Age ~ 48 years)
Robert Stewart’s information is presented below.
2. Mary Stewart, b. Abt 1705, Dalveich, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland, d. UNKNOWN
Mary Stewart, b. Abt 1705, Dalveich, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN.
Mary Stewart is recorded in the Comrie OPR as being the wife of Duncan McNab from Easter Glentarken. She is presumed but not confirmed to be the daughter of Alexander Stewart whose son Robert was living in Easter Glentarken at the same time.
-
- Janet McNab, b. 29 Mar 1730, Easter Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Donald McNab, b. 20 Apr 1732, Easter Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Alexander McNab, b. 5 May 1734, Easter Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Christian McNab, b. 16 Sep 1736, Easter Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Robert McNab, b. 18 Sep 1737, Easter Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Anna McNab, b. 11 May 1740, Easter Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Margaret McNab, b. 6 Dec 1742, Easter Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN. She is believed to be the Margaret McNab who married Alexander Campbell-alias-McGregor, b. Abt 1740, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN and had the following family:
- Catharine Campbell-alias-McGregor, b. 1761, Bridge End of Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN, Rannag of Glenogle, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland . Catharine is believed to have married John Clark, b. Abt 1760, Rannag of Glenogle, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN, Rannag of Glenogle, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland .
- Mary Campbell-alias-McGregor, b. 1764, Bridge End of Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN. Mary is believed to have married Alexander McLaren, b. Abt 1760, Ardveich, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN, Ardveich, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland .
- Euphemia Campbell-alias-McGregor, b. 1766, Bridge End of Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN.
Euphemia McGregor had two illegitimate children: Allan Stewart in 1787 by James Og Stewart in Wester Ardveich, and Janet McDiarmid in 1790 by Daniel McDiarmid in Easter Ardveich. James Og Stewart later married Catherine McDiarmid. It seems likely that Catherine and Daniel were related.
“1787 Augt 22nd Jas Stewart in W. Ardveich & Euphan McGrigor had their son born in uncleanness Bapt this day named Allan.”
“1790 Janry 3rd Daniel McDiarmid in E. Ardveich and Euphan McGrigor in E. Glentarkin had their Daughter born in fornication Bapd Janet.”
“Comrie 15th March 1789 Euphan McGrigor an unmarried woman in Ester Ardveich with child. Donald McDiarmid servg man to Alexr McLaren in said town at time guilt committed, now in Callander, father.” (Comrie Kirk Session Minutes)Euphemia had relations firstly with James Og Stewart, in Stronvar, b. Abt 1 Aug 1765, Wester Ardveich, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN of 5-Line The Ross Stewarts in Ardveich & Stronvar. Euphemia had relations secondly with Daniel McDiarmid, b. Abt 1770, Easter Ardveich, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN . They had the following illegitimate children:
- Allan Stewart, b. 22 Aug 1787, Wester Ardveich, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN. Allan was the illegitmate child of James Stewart in Wester Ardviech and Euphemia McGregor in Easter Glentarken.
“1787 Augt 22nd Jas Stewart in W. Ardveich & Euphan McGrigor had their son born in uncleanness Bapt this day named Allan.” (Comrie OPR)
The Kirk Session minutes for Comrie Parish record the following: “Comrie 10th Febry 1788 James Stewart in Ardveich guilty of adultery with Euphan McGregor in Ester Glentarkin.”
The name “Allan” is an unusual choice for the baby’s name. The name does not occur in either parent’s family. It’s possible that he could have been named after the infamous Allan Breck Stewart who was known to frequent the area and was allied with the Stewarts of Balquhidder. Baby Allan disappears from records after his birth and is presumed to have died in childhood.
Allan Stewart was descended from John Dubh Mhor Stewart in Dalveich on both his father and mother’s side.
- Janet McDiarmid, b. 3 Jan 1790, Easter Ardveich, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Allan Stewart, b. 22 Aug 1787, Wester Ardveich, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN. Allan was the illegitmate child of James Stewart in Wester Ardviech and Euphemia McGregor in Easter Glentarken.
- Duncan Campbell-alias-McGregor, b. 1768, Bridge End of Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN, Rannag of Glenogle, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland . Duncan married on 2 Jan 1796 in Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland to Catherine Campbell-alias-McAinsh, b. Abt 1770, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN, Rannag of Glenogle, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland .
- James McNab, b. 8 Dec 1745, Easter Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Elizabeth McNab, b. 13 May 1749, Easter Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN.
She is believed to be the Elizabeth McNab from Easter Glentarken who married Duncan McNaughton from Morell in Easter Glentarken. There was a family of McNabs in Easter Glentarken at the time, namely the family of Duncan McNab and Margaret Stewart shown here as the parents of this Elizabeth McNab. They had a family as shown here, but their last child’s name is not recorded in the Comrie OPR. It just shows McNab daughter born 13 May 1749. She’s the perfect age and living in the same location as her husband shown here.
Elizabeth McNab married on 5 Aug 1771 in Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland to Duncan McNaughtan, b. Abt 12 Jun 1747, Morell, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. 1799, Scotland (Age ~ 51 years). They had the following children:
- Catharine McNaughtan, b. 16 Jul 1774, Morell, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. Sep 1848, Puslinch, Wellington, Ontario, Canada (Age 74 years). Catharine married on 4 Dec 1795 in Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland to her second-cousin, Robert Stewart, in Morell, b. Abt 8 May 1762, Easter Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. Abt 1830, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland (Age ~ 67 years). Robert’s information is presented further below.
- Their children are shown further below on this page.
- Colin McNaughtan, b. 18 Sep 1776, Morell, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Peter McNaughtan, b. Abt 20 Apr 1778, Morell, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN. Peter McNaughtan married on 25 Jan 1801 in Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland to his second-cousin, Margaret Stewart, b. Abt 22 Mar 1772, Easter Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN. She was the sister of Robert Stewart in Morell who married Peter’s sister, Catharine McNaughtan, above.
- Their children are shown further below.
- Duncan McNaughtan, b. Abt 1780, Morell, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN. There is no documentary evidence of the existence of this Duncan. He is suggested by onomastics and chronology only. If he existed at all then it is suggested that he probably died young.
- John McNaughtan, b. Abt 1 Sep 1782, Morell, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Robert McNaughtan, b. Abt 1 May 1785, Morell, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. Between 1851 and 1861 (Age ~ 65 years). Robert McNaughtan married Between 26 and 29 Mar 1814 in Balquhidder and Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland to Elisabeth McArthur, b. 1793, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. Between 1851 and 1861 (Age 58 years). They had the following family:
- Duncan McNaughtan, b. Abt 23 May 1815, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Elisabeth McNaughtan, b. Abt 2 Apr 1820, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Peter McNaughtan, b. Abt 13 Jun 1822, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Janet McNaughtan, b. Abt 14 Jul 1824, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- John McNaughtan, b. Abt 23 Apr 1826, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Colin McNaughtan, b. Abt Nov 1828, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Catharine McNaughtan, b. Abt 15 Sep 1831, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Hugh McNaughtan, b. Abt 16 Dec 1834, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Catharine McNaughtan, b. 16 Jul 1774, Morell, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. Sep 1848, Puslinch, Wellington, Ontario, Canada (Age 74 years). Catharine married on 4 Dec 1795 in Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland to her second-cousin, Robert Stewart, in Morell, b. Abt 8 May 1762, Easter Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. Abt 1830, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland (Age ~ 67 years). Robert’s information is presented further below.
3. Donald Stewart, in Carnlia, b. Abt 1715, Perthshire, Scotland, d. UNKNOWN, Carnlia, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland
Donald Stewart, in Carnlia, b. Abt 1715, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN, Carnlia, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland .
Information on Donald Stewart is presented further below on this page.
The Stewarts in Easter Glentarken
Robert Stewart in Ardveich
Robert Stewart, in Ardveich, b. Nov 1697, Dalveich, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. 16 Apr 1746, Culloden, Inverness, Scotland (Age ~ 48 years), shown above as the eldest son of Alexander mac Iain Dubh Stewart in Dalveich.
“Alexander (or John) Steuart in Dalveich had a child baptized and called Robert. (Date given is Nobr 1697, but no day.) We have two conflicting transcriptions of this entry, however a review would favour that Alexander is the correct reading.” (Balquhidder OPR)
Robert is shown in the Comrie OPR as living in Ardveich when his son John was born.
Family tradition in the branch of his Canadian great-grandchild, Duncan Stewart, recalls that Robert was killed at the Battle of Culloden. Such a claim is supported by the fact that Robert and Mary appear to have stopped having children after 1744.
If Robert died at Culloden and left his widow with a houseful of young children, then she likely would have either remarried or been taken in by a close relative. Further research is needed to see if a second family can be identified for her.
Robert Stewart is presumed to have married Mary Stewart, b. Abt 1705, Perthshire, Scotland , d. Aft 1744, although no record has been found of their marriage. Her birth family is unknown but she was likely a distant cousin from another line of the Dalveich Stewarts. They had the following children:
1. John Stewart, in Easter Glentarken, b. Abt 8 Feb 1734, Ardveich, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland, d. Abt 1820, Lochearnside, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland
John Stewart, in Easter Glentarken, b. Abt 8 Feb 1734, Ardveich, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. Abt 1820, Lochearnside, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland (Age ~ 85 years).
John Stewart’s information is presented below.
2. Margaret Stewart, b. Abt 16 Dec 1744, Comrie parish, Perthshire, Scotland, d. UNKNOWN
Margaret Stewart, b. Abt 16 Dec 1744, Comrie parish, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN.
Margaret’s birth is uncertain. The following entry in the Balquhidder OPR is suspected to be from this family.
“1744 DEC 16, Robert Steuart and ___ Steuart in ~ Comrie parish had a child baptised called Margaret.”
It is suggested that Robert Steuart, living in Ardveich, or possibly now living in Glen Tarken, having been born in Balquhidder parish may have returned to Balquhidder for the baptism of his daughter Margaret or it may simply have been recorded in the Balquhidder register.
John Stewart in Easter Glentarken
John Stewart, in Easter Glentarken, b. Abt 8 Feb 1734, Ardveich, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. Abt 1820, Lochearnside, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland (Age ~ 85 years), shown above as the only son of Robert Stewart in Ardveich.
John Stewart was born in Ardveich, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland, on the border with Balquhidder parish. Family tradition says that his father, Robert, died at the Battle of Culloden in 1745. This is supported by the fact that no births for siblings of John can be identified later than 1744. Assuming the tradition to be true, then John’s mother would likely have either remarried or been taken in by a close relative. John would have been 11-years-old at the time of his father’s death. Further research is required to determine who may have raised John as a young boy.
Little more is known about John other than by 1762, at the latest, he ended up in the flax weaving community of Easter Glentarken where his children were born. There is no record of his marriage to Margaret McLaren as there were no marriages recorded in the Comrie OPR between 1752-1769. The parish register states: “Marriages in the parish of Comrie Whitsunday 1769 – none of which having been registered since March 1752.” (Whitsunday/Pentecost occurs in late May or early June.)
Circumstantial evidence suggests that John Stewart may have been still alive in 1818 when the Carmichael family left Wester Glentarken for Ontario, Canada, and that he died very shortly afterwards. John would have been in his early 80s by this time.
In March 1834, _____ Carmichael in Wester Glentarken, wrote to his brother, John Carmichael in London, Ontario, Canada. (John Carmichael was born in Wester Glentarken. He had been part of the party who emigrated on the Curlew in 1818 and initially settled in Carleton Place, Ontario, but later moved to London, Ontario, Canada). The letter is damaged and only partially readable. The writer mentions local families who are “bound for Canada” in which he says,
“John McLarens son in Careglen (Carroglen, just above Comrie village) is going away one Peter and their was two of the sons away before…(illegible) of theirs a son of John [are] all Stuarts it was at lochearnside & James Carmichael Lochearnside who learned the shoemaking. Comrie Donald Carmichaels son & one Peter McIntyre from Lochearnside who learned the shoe making with James Mingas a son of Alex Stirlings and it is reported a son of Donald Galech Cowan I think all bound for Canada.”
A rewrite of this extract correcting likely grammar and punctuation errors, might render it:
“…John McLaren’s son in Carroglen is going away. One Peter (McLaren), and there [were] two of [his] sons away before…. [missing text*] of their’s, a son of John Stewart’s, [who] was at Lochearnside, and James Carmichael at Lochearnside, who learned shoemaking. Comrie Donald Carmichael’s son and one Peter McIntyre from Lochearnside, who learned shoemaking with James Mingas, a son of Alex Stirling’s, and it is reported a son of Donald Galech Cowan — I think [are] all bound for Canada.”
*If the missing text happens to say “a cousin (of theirs)” then this could also fit our John Stewart, as his wife was Margaret McLaren, possible daughter of Patrick McLaren. This would fit to make Robert Stewart a cousin of the Peter McLaren mentioned in the letter.
The reference to “Lochearnside” from someone writing from Comrie parish to someone who had grown up there would most likely refer to the east end of the loch, namely St. Fillans and environs. According to Stewarts of the South, there were only two Stewart households in St. Fillans ca. 1820, namely Robert Stewart, son of this John Stewart, and his distant cousin, Lt. Alexander Stewart, son of Robert Stewart in Dalveich.
The Peter McLaren who was “away before” could be John Stewart’s father-in-law or brother-in-law.
Peter McIntyre mentioned as “bound for Canada” is likely the one who migrated to Horton Twp, Renfrew County, Ontario, in 1832.
John Carmichael in London (1784-1872) was married to Mary McLaren (1790-1873)
There are only two John Stewarts, Lochearnside, in Comrie parish, in Stewarts of the South. This John Stewart and John Stewart in Ardveich and Keip, Lochearnside son John m Christian dtr of Duncan McIntyre moved to Renfrew, Ontario in 1829-1832 (likely with Peter McIntyre, above.) That John Stewart was gone by the time the letter was written, but would have been around in 1818.
The reference to “a son of John Stuarts it was at lochearnside” is a past-tense reference, possibly indicating that either John or his son or both were already deceased. This would fit the chronology of this family. The fact that the author would refer to John and not Robert Stewart suggests that John may have been still alive in 1818 when John Carmichael left, so that would be the most noteworthy person that John Carmichael would have remembered as a point of reference.
A subsequent Carmichael letter written the very next day mentions “Mrs. Thomson who is going out from this place to the District of Gore (Ontario)” who was going to deliver the letter in person to John Carmichael and “who has taken in hand to forward this to you.” The district of Gore refers to the area of the present-day city of Hamilton, Ontario, Canada, where John Stewart’s son, Robert’s family ended up.
Stewarts of the South, written sometime between 1818-1820, refers to John’s son, Robert as being a feuer in St. Fillans. If our above identification of John Stewart is correct, that could indicate that he died between 1818-1820, which would put him in his mid-80s, a reasonable age.
John Stewart married Margaret McLaren, b. Abt 1740, Balquhidder or Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN. They had the following children:
1. Robert Stewart, in Morell, b. Abt 8 May 1762, Easter Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland, d. Abt 1830, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland
Robert Stewart, in Morell, b. Abt 8 May 1762, Easter Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. Abt 1830, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland (Age ~ 67 years).
Robert Stewart was born in 1762 in the clachan of Easter Glentarken on the north shore of Loch Earn in Perthshire, Scotland. Following Scottish custom, he was named after his paternal grandfather, Robert Stewart in Ardveich, who, according to family tradition, was a Jacobite who was killed at the Battle of Culloden fighting for Bonnie Prince Charlie. (Comrie parish records support this tradition.)
Stewarts of the South indicates that Robert Stewart was a descendant of John Dubh Mhor Stewart of Dalveich, natural son of James Beag Stewart, 2nd of Ardvorlich. The document also describes Robert as “an industrious and well-doing man”.
On 4 Dec 1795, Robert Stewart married his second-cousin, Catharine McNaughtan. His paternal great-grandfather, Alexander Stewart in Ardveich was her maternal great-grandather.
In the early 1800s, Glen Tarken belonged to the Earl of Perth, and sometime during the early 1800s the Earl emptied Glen Tarken and moved all of the crofters to the nearby village of St. Fillans. The houses they once lived in were left to fall into ruin. As Robert’s son, Peter, recalls growing up in St. Fillans, then it is presumed that Robert Stewart’s birth family would have been among those who were moved.
Stewarts of the South (ca. 1818) indicates that Robert Stewart was a feuer (a feudal land holder, like a tenant) in St. Fillans on the estate of Sir John Drummond, Earl of Perth.
Stewarts of the South also indicates that Robert had a close relative named Alexander Stewart, living in Dalveich. They were second-cousins.
Sometime between 1825-1830 (more likely closer to 1830), Robert died, presumably of natural causes (he would have been in his mid-60s) and the croft passed to his sons. A few short years after Robert’s death, his widow, Catharine, and all their children, as well as a couple of young grandchildren, left Scotland for good, and headed to Canada.
Robert and Catharine seem to have followed the traditional Scottish naming custom more strictly for their sons, but less strictly for their daughters. Their eldest son was named John after his paternal grandfather, their second son was named Duncan after his maternal grandfather, and their third son was named Robert after his father. However, their first daughter was named Margaret after her paternal grandmother, and their second daughter was named Elisabeth after her maternal grandmother, thus reversing the traditional order. Their next three daughters seem to have been named after Robert’s sisters. It’s not until their sixth daughter that they name a daughter after her mother.
Robert Stewart married on 4 Dec 1795 in Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland to his second-cousin, Catharine McNaughtan, b. 16 Jul 1774, Morell, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. Sep 1848, Puslinch, Wellington, Ontario, Canada (Age 74 years). They had the following children:
-
- Margaret Stewart, b. Abt 10 Jun 1798, Morell, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. 21 May 1891, Hamilton, Wentworth, Ontario, Canada (Age ~ 92 years)
- Elisabeth Stewart, b. Abt 27 Oct 1799, Morell, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN, Probably Canada
- Mary Stewart, b. Abt 2 May 1802, Morell, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN, Probably Canada
- Jean Stewart, b. Abt 7 Jun 1804, Morell, Comrie Parish, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Ann Stewart, b. Abt 1 Jun 1806, Morell, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN, Probably Canada
- John Stewart, b. Abt 1 Sep 1808, Morell, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Duncan Stewart, b. Abt 2 Jan 1811, Morell, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. 1895, Bayham Township, Elgin County, Ontario, Canada (Age ~ 83 years)
- Robert Stewart, Jr., b. Abt 13 Jun 1813, Morell, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. Jan 1849, Puslinch, Wellington, Ontario, Canada (Age ~ 35 years)
- Catharine Stewart, b. Abt 24 Mar 1816, Morell, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. 22 Mar 1904, Puslinch, Wellington, Ontario, Canada (Age ~ 88 years)
- Peter Stewart, b. Abt 24 Jul 1820, Morell, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. 3 Dec 1901, Puslinch, Wellington, Ontario, Canada (Age ~ 81 years)
- William Stewart, b. Abt 22 Nov 1824, Morell, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. 15 Feb 1892, Hamilton, Wentworth, Ontario, Canada (Age ~ 67 years)
Extensive descendant information on this family can be found on Ryk Brown’s Genealogy Site.
2. Mary Stewart, b. Abt 26 Jun 1767, Easter Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland, d. 1837
Mary Stewart, b. Abt 26 Jun 1767, Easter Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. 1837 (Age ~ 69 years)
She is believed to be the Mary Stewart from Comrie parish who married Duncan McIntyre from Achra and had a family in Leachin and Dalveich. There are only two Mary Stewarts born in Comrie in the right date range to have married in 1785 to Duncan McIntyre. The other Mary Stewart is recorded as having married Peter Ferguson in St. Fillans. A third option is Mary Stewart, b 1757 in Dalveich, daughter of Donald Stewart, but there is no evidence that Donald’s family later moved to Comrie parish, and Mary had no sons named Donald, so that family can likely be eliminated. That leaves the family of John Stewart and Margaret McLaren in Easter Glentarken and latterly in St. Fillans as the only viable option for Mary’s birth family.
Private papers for “Mary Stewart in Glentarken (1767-1837)” are referenced in a modern cookbook in which Mary describes the quality and usages for home-churned butter in the Highlands in the late 1700s. The reference also gives us Mary’s date of death.
“…from a manuscript study of the Life and Times of Mary Stewart (1767-1837), a native of Glentarken in Perthshire, written by her great-grandson in conjunction with Mrs. N. Watt of Comrie:
“‘Butter, on the farms, was used for cooking, but was not otherwise usually eaten; for the most part it was mixed with Archangel tar and smeared on sheep; the butter and the natural oil in the fleece gave resistance to wet, and the tar had an antiseptic quality.’
“Predictably, though, the scarcity of fat for cooking meant that such things as pies became luxury items: vegetable oils were not used at the time.
“Several of the more fastidious early travellers in Scotland were repelled by the butter. One can sympathise with their complaint that it was invariably full of cows’ hairs.”
(The Good Scots Diet and What Happened to It? by Maise Steven, Aberdeen University Press, July 1, 1985, p. 41)
Mary’s marriage was registered in Balquhidder and Comrie:
22 jan 1785 • Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland. Contracted Duncan McIntyre in Achra and Mary Stewart in the parish of Comrie dues 2s str.
14 feb 1785 • Comrie Perthshire. Dun McIntyre Balquhidder parish and Mary Stewart in this were listed and after being regularly proclaimed were married 14 Febry
Mary Stewart married as noted above to Duncan McIntyre, b. Abt 1760, Dalveich, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN. They had the following children:
-
- John McIntyre, b. Abt 16 Oct 1785, Leachin of Achra (near Dalveich), Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- James McIntyre, b. Abt 8 Apr 1787, Achra, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Katharine McIntyre, b. Abt 26 Oct 1788, Leachin of Achra (near Dalveich), Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Margaret McIntyre, b. Abt 12 Dec 1790, Dalveich, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. 16 Sep 1876, Derry, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland (Age ~ 85 years). Margaret McIntyre married on 30 May 1813 in Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland to Duncan McLaren, Sr. in Ardveich and Derry, b. 7 Feb 1780, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. 14 Jan 1860, Derry, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland (Age 79 years) Margaret was predeceased by 5 of her 9 children. They had the following children:
- Mary McLaren, b. 28 Feb 1814, Derry, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Duncan McLaren, b. 20 Jan 1816, Derry, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. Bef 1834 (Age < 17 years)
- Alexander McLaren, b. 10 Mar 1818, Derry, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. Bef 1841, Derry, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland (Age < 22 years)
- John McLaren, b. 28 May 1820, Derry, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. Between 1841 and 1851, Derry, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland (Age 20 years)
- Grissel Grace McLaren, b. 10 Oct 1822, Derry, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Margaret McLaren, b. 1825, Derry, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. 3 Jun 1901, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland (Age 76 years)
- Janet McLaren, b. 22 Jan 1827, Derry, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. Bef 1851 (Age < 23 years)
- Catherine McLaren, b. 26 May 1830, Derry, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. Bef 1851 (Age < 20 years)
- Duncan Mclaren, Jr., b. 20 Jul 1833, Derry, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN. Duncan McLaren Jr married on 18 Dec 1860 in Killin, Perthshire, Scotland to Margaret Campbell, b. 1832, Killin, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN. They had the following children:
- Duncan Mclaren, b. 1861, Wester Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland
- Peter McLaren, b. 1863, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- John McLaren, b. 1867, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland
- Alastair McLaren, b. 1869, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland
- Colin McLaren, b. 1871, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland
- Christian McLaren, b. 1873, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland
- Margaret McLaren, b. 1876, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland
- Janet McIntyre, b. Abt 13 Jan 1793, Dalveich, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
3. Janet Stewart, b. Abt 8 Oct 1769, Easter Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland, d. UNKNOWN
Janet Stewart, b. Abt 8 Oct 1769, Easter Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN.
According to the Walker Family History, Alexander Stewart in Carnlia married Janet Stewart “of Lochearnside whose mother was a McLaren”. Lochearnside is often used to refer to Port of Lochearn before it was called St. Fillans.
Janet Stewart married on 8 Dec 1792 in Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland, to her first-cousin-once-removed, Alexander Stewart in Carnlia, son of Donald Stewart in Carnial, shown further below on this page. They had the following children:
-
- John Stewart, b. Abt 2 Feb 1794, Carnlia, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Donald Stewart, b. Abt 20 Mar 1796, Carnlia, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. Bef 1813 (Age ~ 16 years)
- Robert Stewart, b. Abt 12 Jan 1800, Carnlia, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Isabel Stewart, b. Abt 28 Mar 1802, Carnlia, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Patrick Stewart, b. Abt 17 Jun 1804, Carnlia, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Margaret Stewart, b. Abt 14 May 1806, Carnlia, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. 17 Aug 1879, Mortlake, New South Wales, Australia (Age ~ 73 years)
- Alexander Stewart, b. Abt 12 Feb 1809, Carnlia, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Daniel Stewart, b. Abt 4 Jun 1813, Carnlia, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
This family is presented more fully further below under the Stewarts in Carnlia.
4. Margaret Stewart, b. Abt 22 Mar 1772, Easter Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland, d. UNKNOWN
Margaret Stewart, b. Abt 22 Mar 1772, Easter Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
She is believed, but not confirmed, to be the Margaret Stewart who married on 25 Jan 1801 in Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland to Peter McNaughtan, b. Abt 20 Apr 1778, Morell, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN, brother of Catharine McNaughtan who married Margaret Stewart’s brother, Robert Stewart in Morell. Margaret Stewart and Peter McNaughtan had the following children:
-
- Duncan McNaughtan, b. 7 Feb 1802, Dalchonzie, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Margaret McNaughtan, b. Abt 4 Jun 1803, Dalchonzie, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Christian McNaughtan, b. 7 Apr 1805, Dalchonzie, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Janet McNaughtan, b. 5 Apr 1807, Dalchonzie, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Cathrine McNaughtan, b. 26 Feb 1809, Dalchonzie, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- John McNaughtan, b. 12 Apr 1812, Dalchonzie, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Helen McNaughtan, b. 8 Oct 1815, Dalchonzie, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
5. Ann Stewart, b. 1 Nov 1774, Easter Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland, d. UNKNOWN
Ann Stewart, b. 1 Nov 1774, Easter Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN.
Ann has not been found in later records. Nothing more is known about her.
6. Isbal Stewart, b. 20 Jul 1777, Easter Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland, d. UNKNOWN
Isbal Stewart, b. 20 Jul 1777, Easter Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN.
Isabel Stewart has not been located in later records. Nothing more is known about her.
Further information on the descendants of Robert Stewart in Morell can be found on Ryk Brown’s genealogy page:
The Stewarts in Carnlia
Donald Stewart in Carnlia
Donald Stewart, b. Abt 1715, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN, Carnlia, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland
Donald is believed to be the Donald Stewart, son of Alexander and Janet Stewart, bap. 4 SEP 1720 in Auchleskine, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland as the only known child of this couple. As Auchleskine is not far from Glenbeich, the Auchleskine birth is a reasonable suggestion. According to The Walker Family History, Donald resided at Carnlia and married a daughter of Alexander MacGregor of Woodside of Lochearn of Clan Dughail Chiar. (Clan Dugal Ciar, or the Clan of sable-haired Douglas; this was the chief’s family.) There are only two marriages in the Balquhidder or Comrie OPR for a Donald Stewart with any MacGregor in the right date range. This one happens to be in Dalveich and the other one has been identified with a different family, confirming that this is the marriage noted in the Walker History. Donald’s suggested birth place of Auchleskine was also occupied by a family of MacGregors descended from Sir Gregor MacGregor of Clan Dughail Chiar — so that too would be consistent.
Donald Stewart married on 10 Apr 1756 in Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland to Isabel McGregor, b. Abt 1735, Woodside of Lochearn, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN. They had the following children:
1. Mary Stewart, b. Abt 11 Jun 1758, Dalveich, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland, d. UNKNOWN
Mary Stewart, b. Abt 11 Jun 1758, Dalveich, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN.
Mary Stewart married on 13 May 1785 in Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland to Peter Dochardach, in Wester Glentarken, b. Abt 1750, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN. They had the following children:
-
- Isabel Dochardach, b. 16 Apr 1786, Wester Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Mary Dochardach, b. 20 Jun 1788, Wester Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- John Dochardach, b. 20 Mar 1790, Wester Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Donald Dochardach, b. 16 Nov 1794, Wester Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Alexander Dochardach, b. 30 Apr 1797, Wester Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Peter Dochardach, b. 21 Oct 1798, Wester Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Alexander Dochardach, b. 9 Jan 1803, Wester Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
2. John Stewart, b. Abt 23 Mar 1760, Dalveich, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland, d. UNKNOWN
John Stewart, b. Abt 23 Mar 1760, Dalveich, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN.
John Stewart has not been identified in later records. He is not mentioned in Stewarts of the South. Nothing more is known about him.
3. Catharine Stewart, b. Abt 28 Jul 1762, Dalveich, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland, d. UNKNOWN
Catharine Stewart, b. Abt 28 Jul 1762, Dalveich, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN.
According to Cameron family records, Catherine Stewart, daughter of Donald Stewart and Isobel McGregor, married Duncan Cameron, and were the parents of John Cameron who married Helen Ferguson of Kipp, Balquhidder, and had nine children born at Glenbeich, Balquhidder. Documentary evidence is lacking to support the Cameron/Stewart connection, however the claim seems probably true. The Stewarts were from Dalveich, next door to Glenbeich, and multiple autosomal DNA connections exist between descendants of the Camerons and this Dalveich line. The Camerons immigrated to Canada in 1831. Research has eliminated the possibility of a marital connection between these families post-immigration, thus the connection must earlier than John Cameron and Helen Ferguson. Thus the connection suggested here, though not proven, becomes more than plausible, in fact probable.
Catharine Stewart married on 18 Dec 1791 in Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland to Donald Cameron, b. Abt 1760, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN. They had the following children:
-
- John Cameron, b. 27 Feb 1793, Lochearnhead, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
- Robert Cameron, b. 27 Feb 1793, Lochearnhead, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
4. Jannet Stewart, b. Abt 24 Jul 1764, Dalveich, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland, d. UNKNOWN
Jannet Stewart, b. Abt 24 Jul 1764, Dalveich, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN.
Jannet has not been identified in later records.
5. Alexander Stewart, b. Abt 20 Jun 1767, Dalveich, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland, d. UNKNOWN
Alexander Stewart, in Carnlia, b. Abt 20 Jun 1767, Dalveich, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN.
Alexander’s information is presented below.
Alexander Stewart in Carnlia and Janet Stewart in Easter Glentarken
Union of the two branches
Alexander Stewart, b. Abt 20 Jun 1767, Dalveich, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN.
Stewarts of the South describes Alexander as “Alexander Stewart, who is a tacksman in Dalveich, Balquhidder parish on Breadalbane’s estate. He has three sons — one adult and two under age.” It indicates that Alexander is closely related to Robert Stewart in St. Fillans but does not indicate their relationship.
The Walker Family History says that “Alexander Stewart married Janet Stewart [in] Lochearnside. Her mother’s name was MacLaren.” This family is easily identifiable in the OPR. Alexander Stewart married on 08 DEC 1792 in Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland to his first-cousin-once-removed Janet Stewart, sister of the aformentioned Robert Stewart in Morell and daughter of John Stewart in Easter Glentarken and Margaret McLaren of this line (above). In their marriage, the two lines of this family (Carnlia and Glentarken) come together.
Alexander Stewart married on 8 Dec 1792 in Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland to Janet Stewart, b. Abt 8 Oct 1769, Easter Glentarken, Comrie, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN, daughter of John Stewart in Easter Glentarken, shown above. They had the following children:
1. John Stewart, b. Abt 2 Feb 1794, Carnlia, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
John Stewart, b. Abt 2 Feb 1794, Carnlia, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN.
John Stewart has not been identified in later records. Nothing more is known about him.
2. Donald Stewart, b. Abt 20 Mar 1796, Carnlia, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland, d. Bef 1813
Donald Stewart, b. Abt 20 Mar 1796, Carnlia, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. Bef 1813 (Age ~ 16 years).
Donald is presumed to have died young prior to the birth of his same-named younger brother, Daniel in 1813.
3. Robert Stewart, b. Abt 12 Jan 1800, Carnlia, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland, d. UNKNOWN
Robert Stewart, b. Abt 12 Jan 1800, Carnlia, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
Robert Stewart has not been found in later records. Nothing more is known about him.
4. Isabel Stewart, b. Abt 28 Mar 1802, Carnlia, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland, d. UNKNOWN
Isabel Stewart, b. Abt 28 Mar 1802, Carnlia, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
Isabel Stewart has not been found in later records. Nothing more is known of her.
5. Patrick Stewart, b. Abt 17 Jun 1804, Carnlia, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland, d. UNKNOWN
Patrick Stewart, b. Abt 17 Jun 1804, Carnlia, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
Patrick Stewart has not been found in later records. Nothing more is known of him.
6. Margaret Stewart, b. Abt 14 May 1806, Carnlia, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland, d. 17 Aug 1879, Mortlake, New South Wales, Australia
Margaret Stewart, b. Abt 14 May 1806, Carnlia, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. 17 Aug 1879, Mortlake, New South Wales, Australia (Age ~ 73 years).
Balquhidder Parish: 1845 March 1 Contracted John McGregor Parish of St. ~ and Margaret Stewart in this Parish. 10pIn 1851, John and Margaret were residing at East Muir Cottage, Landrick, Kilmadock, Perthshire, Scotland, with their two youngest daughters and John’s mother, Isabella McGregor. Eldest daughter, Mary, has not been found in 1851, but did accompany the family to Australia in 1852.Margaret Stewart married on Between 1 and 2 Mar 1845 in Balquhidder, Perthshire and St. Ninian’s, Stirlingshire, Scotland Jno McGregor, b. 1808, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. 21 Feb 1884, Mortlake, Victoria, Australia (Age 76 years). They had the following children:
-
- Mary McGregor, b. Abt 1836, Dalveich, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN, Australia
- Janet McGregor, b. 1846, St Ninians, Stirlingshire, Scotland , d. 24 Jul 1931, Camperdown, Victoria, Australia (Age 85 years)
- Isabella McGregor, b. 1848, St Ninians, Stirlingshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN, Australia . She was the mother of:
- Daniel Stewart McGregor, b. 1870, Mortlake, New South Wales, Australia , d. UNKNOWN, Australia
7. Alexander Stewart, in Cuilt, b. Abt 12 Feb 1809, Carnlia, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN.
Alexander Stewart, in Cuilt, b. Abt 12 Feb 1809, Carnlia, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN.
According to The Walker Family History, Alexander Stewart was born at Carnlia about 1809 and married Margaret Dewar from Killin, she being born about 1820. According to descendant Donald Walker, Alexander had only one (surviving) child, Alexander Jr. Alexander Sr. would have been 47-years-old at the time of his marriage. This is late to start a family, which suggests the possibility that Alexander Sr. may have had a previous family. However, no record of any such family has been found and census records give no indication of any previous family, which confirms the family record that Alexander started his family very late and had only one child.
Alexander Stewart has not been found in 1841 or 1851. He may have been residing in Killin at the time where his wife was from.
In 1861, at age 51, Alexander Stewart was residing at Carnlia in Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland (incorrectly transcribed as “Castle” on Ancestry) with his wife, and 1-year-old son, Alexander. Alexander Sr. was employed as a shepherd. There is no indication of any earlier family living with Alexander.
In 1871, at age 60, Alexander Stewart was residing at Auchtowmore in Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland with his wife and son. He was employed as a shepherd.
In 1881, at age 71, Alexander Stewart was residing at Craggan in Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland with his wife and son. He is listed as having no occupation.
In 1891, Alexander’s widow, Margaret, was residing at Craggan in Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland, alone and recorded as “living on private means.”
Alexander Stewart in Cuilt married on 1 Jul 1856 in Killin, Perthshire, Scotland to Margaret Dewar, b. 1819, Killin, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland . They had the following child:
-
- Janet Stewart, b. 27 Apr 1857 in Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland. Janet is not found with her parents in 1861 and is presumed to have died in infancy.
- Sgt. Alexander Stewart, b. 7 Jan 1860, Cuilt, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. 17 Feb 1926, Falkirk, Stirlingshire, Scotland (Age 66 years)
According to The Walker Family History, Alexander Stewart was born 7 Jan 1860 with no place given. However, his obituary says that he was born at Cuilt.Alexander later moved to Falkirk where he worked on the railroad and later became a police officer. He was an award-winning Gaelic scholar and poet. He is believed to be the Alexander Stewart, poet/police officer who published the Ben Ledi View newspaper in Callander.In 1861, at age 1, Alexander Stewart was residing in Cuilt, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland as an infant with his parents.
In 1871, at age 11, Alexander Stewart was residing in Auchtow Mor, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland as an only child with his parents. He was a student at the time.
In 1881, at age 21, Alexander Stewart was residing in Craggan in Strathyre, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland with his parents. He was employed as a railway surfaceman.
Sometime between 1881-1891, Alexander Stewart married to a woman named Mary. Her surname is unknown. No record of their marriage has been found.
In 1891, at age 31, Alexander Stewart was residing in Bridgehill Square, Muiravonside, Stirlingshire, Scotland with his first wife, Mary. He was employed as a police officer.
Sometime between 18901-1901, Alexander Stewart married secondly to Elizabeth Robertson although no record of their marriage has been found.
In 1901, at age 40, Alexander Stewart was residing in Goshen, Larbert, Stirlingshire, Scotland with his wife, Elizabeth, and infant son, John. He was employed as a Sergeant of Police.
On 17 Feb 1926, at age 66, Alexander Stewart died in Falkirk, Stirlingshire, Scotland. His probate index record reads: “Stewart, Alexander, Police Sergeant, retired, Macfarlane Crescent, Falkirk, died 17 Feb 1926 at Falkirk. Testate, confirmation: Stirling, 30 Apr to Elizabeth Robertson or Stewart, Macfarlane Crescent, aforesaid, Executrix. Will dated 26 May 1924, recorded Stirling, 26 Apr 1926. Value of estate, £708:7:6.”
Alexander Stewart married Elizabeth Robertson, b. 1871, Avonbridge, Falkirk, Scotland , d. 12 Jan 1950 (Age 79 years). They had the following children:
- John Robertson Stewart, b. 26 May 1898, Polmont, Stirlingshire, Scotland , d. 23 Jul 1918, Buzancy, Ardennes, France (Age 19 years). “Stewart, John Robertson, signaller, No. 25887, 6th (Service) Battalion, The Queen’s Own Cameron Highlanders, eldest son of Alexander Stewart of Macfarlane Crescent, Falkirk, Sergeant of the Stirlingshire Constabulary, by his wife, Elizabeth, daughter of the late John Robertson of Avonbridge; born Polmont, county Stirling, 16 May 1898; educated Stenhousemuir and Falkirk; was assistant Postman at Falkirk; enlisted in Aug. 1916; served with the Expeditionary Force in France and Flanders from June 1917, and was killed in action near Buzancy, south of Soissons, 23 July 1918. Burried where he fell. Unmarried.”
- Elizabeth Stewart, b. 1901, Falkirk, Stirlingshire, Scotland , d. 14 Nov 1992 (Age 91 years)
- Margaret Dewar Stewart, b. 16 Jun 1903, Falkirk, Stirlingshire, Scotland , d. 25 Nov 1983, Pointe Caire, Quebec, Canada .
According to family records, Margaret (“Peggy”) immigrated to Cape Breton, Nova Scotia, Canada, with her sister Janet in the 1920s. Public records show otherwise.
On 14 Nov 1926, at age 23, Margaret Stewart, born 1903 in Falkirk, departing from Glasgow on the ship Montairn, arrived in Quebec City, Quebec, Canada, bound for the YMCA, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada. Employment in Scotland: Domestic. Intended employment in Canada: Domestic. Next of Kin: Mrs. Elizabeth Stewart, mother, Macfarlane Crescent, Falkirk. Landed Immigrant.
In 1931, at age 26, Margaret Stewart was residing at 89 Sunnyside in Westmount, Montreal, Quebec, Canada, working as a domestic servant for Thomas Redpath (born 1895 in Scotland) whose home was worth $16,000.
Margart Dewar Stewart, daughter of A Stewart and Robertson, died unmarried on 25 Nov 1823 in Pointe Claire, Quebec, Canada.
- Helen Stewart, b. 23 Oct 1906, Falkirk, Stirlingshire, Scotland , d. 30 May 2003, Falkirk, Stirlingshire, Scotland (Age 96 years). Helen (“Nellie”) never married nor had children. She remained in Scotland and is buried with her parents.
- Janet Cissy Stewart, b. Abt 1912, Falkirk, Stirlingshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN, Cape Breton, Nova Scotia, Canada .
According to family records, Janet Stewart immigrated to Cape Breton, Nova Scotia, Canada in the 1920s with her sister Margaret Stewart. Public records show a different story.
Janet’s sister Margaret immigrated in 1926 and arrived in Quebec City, Quebec, Canada, bound for Hamilton, Ontario, Canada. However, in 1931, she was found residing in Westmount, Montreal, Quebec, Canada, working as a domestic servant. A matching Janet Stewart is also found in 1931 in Westmount, Montreal, Quebec, Canada, working as a domestic servant. It is suggested therefore, that Janet moved to Cape Breton after 1931.
Janet married a man named Walker whose first name is not known.
- Christina Stewart, b. Abt 1915, Falkirk, Stirlingshire, Scotland , d. Jan 2020, Falkirk, Stirlingshire, Scotland (Age ~ 105 years)
- Alexander Stewart, b. Abt 1920, Falkirk, Stirlingshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN. His descendants live in Manchester, Lancashire, England.
8. Daniel Stewart, b. Abt 4 Jun 1813, Carnlia, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
Daniel Stewart, b. Abt 4 Jun 1813, Carnlia, Balquhidder, Perthshire, Scotland , d. UNKNOWN
Daniel Stewart has not been found in later records. Nothing more is known of him.